Ammaw’s Heath Bar Coffee Cake

This breakfast treat has a sweet, crunchy topping that makes it so special.We called her Ammaw.

She took me as a newborn baby on an airplane across the country and cared for me for the first three weeks of my life.

I imagine being separated from your newborn for 3 weeks was difficult, but at the time, my parents didn’t have a choice since they were packing up our home for a huge move across many states while also juggling two other young children.

This was the beginning of my very special bond with Ammaw.Ammaw was my grandmother. Jude’s mom. The connection the two of us shared lasted until the end. My mom and I held her hand and comforted her when she passed away.

It is no wonder that my mom was so creative and imaginative herself. She learned from the best. Ammaw was a very talented folk art painter and she could needlepoint the most intricate designs. A visit to her home as a child often involved painting at her kitchen table or needlepointing together in the den.

I think of Ammaw so much this time of year because I have the sweetest collection of hand painted Valentines from her (the bunny and the pink heart box were some of my efforts as a young girl).

She was so classy…and sometimes sassy too. She wore a big smile on her face and had a huge sense of humor, which makes sense since my grandfather was a hysterically funny man. Her home was immaculate and styled to perfection. She was a skilled cook and many of the recipes my mom made through the years originated in my grandmother’s kitchen.
No doubt, in Ammaw’s recipe collection, the one I treasure the most is her Heath Bar Coffee Cake.No matter what time of year we visited my grandparents, she would always have this scrumptious coffee cake for breakfast. As kids, we would polish off one pan of the treat so quickly, that Ammaw would have to whip up another one before our visit ended.

I’m thrilled that I learned to make this cake when I was just a young teenager and have been baking it for my family for years. And for sure, this is about the only baked good I make from scratch and know by heart.You start with the white and brown sugar. How could this not be fabulous with all that brown sugar? To the sugar you add the butter or margarine and cream it together.Add the flour and vanilla and gently combine until you have a dry, crumbly mix. Reserve some of this to make a crispy topping on the cake.After the eggs are added, you pour in your creamy buttermilk.It is the buttermilk that makes this cake so tender and moist.  The tangy buttermilk adds a depth of flavor that is so rich and decadent.

After pouring the batter into the greased pan, the crowning touch is added! Who wouldn’t love to indulge in and have an excuse to eat some candy bars for breakfast?  The melted chocolate isn’t too powerful…you don’t feel like you are eating a rich chocolate treat. It is a perfect balance.And the reserved crumble that’s added next will get crisp when it’s baked. I can’t get enough of this. It’s not overwhelmingly sweet but is definitely a very special delight. And it takes me back to childhood and my Ammaw.

If you’re lucky, you’ll get the perfect bite, the one with the big chunk of chewy, sticky, crunchy toffee.

It has always been a staple at family brunches. Every time I make this, my MC squeals with excitement. I get it, Mags, I used to do the same thing when this Heath Bar Coffee Cake was served. It is the best!

Do you have a special recipe from your grandmother?

4.5 from 8 votes

Print

Ammaw's Heath Bar Coffee Cake

Prep Time

20 mins

Cook Time

40 mins

Total Time

1 hr

 

This breakfast treat has a sweet, crunchy topping that makes it so special.

Course: Breakfast/Brunch

Author: Jen Seislove

Ingredients

• 1 1/2 cups brown sugar
• 3/4 cups white sugar
• 1 1/2 sticks margarine or butter room temperature
• 3 cups flour
• 1 1/2 tsp. vanilla
• 2 eggs
• 1 1/2 tsp baking soda
• 1 1/2 cups buttermilk
• 1 bag of miniature Heath Bar candy bars or 6-8 large Heath Bar candy bars

Instructions

1. Mix softened margarine or butter with brown sugar and white sugar.
2. Add flour and vanilla and gently combine.
3. Take out 3/4 cup of the dry mixture and set aside. This will be your dry crumble topping later.
4. To the dry ingredients, add 2 eggs, the baking soda and the buttermilk.
5. Stir until well combined.
6. Pour mixture in a greased 9x12 dark bottom pan.
7. Break up the candy bars with the back of a spoon or other hard object.
8. Scatter candy pieces onto wet mixture.
9. Top with the reserved dry mixture.
10. Bake at 350 degrees for 40-45 minutes or until when inserted, a toothpick comes out clean.

Recipe Notes

Make sure to use softened butter or margarine, not melted.
Do not overbake or cake will be dry so adjust timing accordingly and start checking your cake with a toothpick at about 35 minutes.
Push some chunks of candy down into batter for a sweet surprise in your bite.

This content uses Affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy for more info.

Shop my favorite kitchen tools.